Best Pies for Thanksgiving

October 20, 2023

Best Pies for Thanksgiving

Slice into this year’s top-rated desserts for Thanksgiving 

As a cherished American holiday, Thanksgiving is more than just a feast—it's a time for family, friends, and loved ones to gather, express gratitude, and, of course, indulge in some of the most delectable culinary creations. At the heart of this sumptuous celebration lies one of its sweetest traditions—pie.

Pies have long held a special place on Thanksgiving tables, serving as the grand finale to a magnificent spread of turkey, stuffing, and all the traditional fixings. Whether you're a fan of the classics like pecan or looking to add a twist to your holiday spread with creative flavors, our journey into the world of the "Best Pies for Thanksgiving" is about to unfold.

As a bonus, we’ve snuck in some additional Thanksgiving dessert ideas that might tickle your turkey’s fancy. 

Must-Try Thanksgiving Pies

Pies are the embodiment of abundance and comfort, making them the perfect addition to the Thanksgiving table. Here is our list of the top three must-try seasonal pies.


#1 - Pecan Pie

Only $24.95!

Of course, at the top of the list of the best pies for Thanksgiving is pecan pie. With every forkful featuring layers of a luscious, caramel-like filling, a flaky, buttery crust, and toasty pecans, it’s hard to imagine a better after-dinner indulgence. The very thought of it warms the heart, making pecan pie a must on every Thanksgiving menu. 

Of course, we're partial to our Pecan Pie. Try our number one ranked pie flavor to indulge in a slice of southern charm. 


#2 - Fudge Pie 

Only $24.95!

Next in our lineup of “Best Thanksgiving Pies” is fudge pie. Imagine a slice of pure indulgence where a fudgy, brownie-like filling meets a buttery, crumbly crust in a harmonious union. The very essence of comfort and extravagance, fudge pie is the dessert that transforms an ordinary meal into an extraordinary feast.

Try our signature Fudge Pie and indulge in an exquisite journey into the world of chocolatey bliss


#3 - Fudge Pecan Pie

Only $26.95!

Last but not least on our list is fudge pecan pie. With a buttery, flaky foundation of delectable crust, a luscious layer of silky chocolate fudge, and a scattering of toasted pecans, a hearty slice of fudge pecan pie is the perfect sweet touch after a savory meal of turkey and mashed potatoes.

Order our Fudge Pecan Pie to satisfy your sweet tooth for both pecan and fudge pie flavors.

Of course, when it comes to finding a variety of delicious desserts perfect for Thanksgiving, there’s no better place to shop than Collin Street Bakery. Keep scrolling to browse our full collection of cakes & bakes on sale to discover all the treats you’ll need to celebrate this season of thanks. 

Tasty Twists on Pumpkin

Pumpkin flavors are a quintessential part of the Thanksgiving experience. As symbols of the harvest, our pumpkin-themed treats help to create a festive and flavorful fall celebration.


Pumpkin Cake 

Only $41.95!

Our Pumpkin Cake is the epitome of autumn on a plate. A delightful blend of tender pumpkin, warm spices, and a luscious cream cheese frosting, our Pumpkin Cake delivers the perfect balance of sweetness and spice. With each forkful, you're transported to a world of cozy gatherings where laughter, love, and gratitude are the centerpiece.

Pumpkin Cheesecake 

Only $30.95!

A tapestry of flavors and textures, our Pumpkin Cheesecake weaves together velvety cheesecake, rich pumpkin puree, and a graham cracker crust that crumbles with every indulgent bite. This dessert is truly a celebration of contrasts—the creaminess and the crunch, the sweetness and the spice.

Supply All the Sweets

When it comes to Thanksgiving desserts, sometimes more is simply better. That's certainly the case with our dessert bundles. Our confectionary combos help you get double the amount of treats but at deliciously discounted prices!

DeLuxe® Fruitcake & Pecan Pie Combo 

Now $5 OFF!

With this dessert duo, you’ll never have to choose between fruitcake or pie again! This bundle starts with our classic DeLuxe® Fruitcake, made with ripe cherries, pineapple, lush papaya, golden raisins, and crunchy pecans gently folded into our lightly sweetened honey batter. Then, it ends with our Pecan Pie, made with warm brown sugar and handfuls of pecans layered atop a base of silky, caramel-like custard. Deck out your holiday dessert table with this iconic duo.

DeLuxe® Fruitcake & Petites Bundle

Now $5 OFF!

Talk about a match made in heaven. We’ve combined our most popular fruitcake and our most popular Petite into one bundle. With one Regular-Sized DeLuxe® Fruitcake and one dozen DeLuxe® Petites per Bundle, this duo is ideal for holiday parties and family gatherings. Whether you prefer to eat your fruitcake by the slice or by the bite, this bundle has it all.

Two Regular-Sized DeLuxe® Fruitcake Bundle

Now $7 OFF!

Our Regular DeLuxe® Fruitcake Bundle is an ideal Thanksgiving treat. With this dessert duo, you’ll be able to keep one cake for yourself while still being able to take the second to your holiday shindig. Tis, in fact, the holiday for sharing! And there's no such thing as too much goodness during this season of thanks.

Talk About A Piece of Cake

Our Texas Pecan Cakes capture the essence of the season with their rich flavor, seasonal availability, versatility, and tradition. Their connection to fall makes them a fitting and delectable addition to any Thanksgiving dessert table.

Cherry Fudge Pecan Cake

Only $39.95!

Our Cherry Fudge Pecan Cake is a delightful medley of rich, fudgy chocolate, roasted Texas pecans, and a burst of sweet, tart cherries. With each bite, your tastebuds will embark on a journey of adventure and discovery that concludes at a destination of delight. 

Apple Cinnamon Pecan Cake

Only $39.95!

Made by combining sweet, spiced apples with roasted Texas pecans, all wrapped in a tender, cinnamon-infused cake, our Apple Cinnamon Pecan Cake is the flavor of the season. Characterized by an addicting spiced aroma, this cake allows your senses to explore the essence of the season without leaving your kitchen. 

Salted Caramel Pecan Cake

Only $39.95!

With rich and silky salted caramel bits and bold, buttery Texas pecans, all nestled within a moist and tender cake, our Salted Caramel Pecan Cake is a top-rated customer favorite. Finished with a sprinkling of salt, this cake is perfect for your Thanksgiving guests who want something sweet but not too sweet. Soft and tender with just the right amount of bite, this cake is the perfect balance of tastes and textures. 

Sharing is Caring

Made from the same delicious recipe as our full-sized cakes, our Petites are the most versatile way to enjoy our DeLuxe®️ Fruitcake and Texas Pecan Cake recipes. Hand-shaped and baked to perfection, our Petites are the perfect pre-feast snack. 

DeLuxe® Petites & Pecan Cake Petites 

All flavors now $4 OFF!

A unique dessert creation made exclusively at Collin Street Bakery, our Petites begin with our award-winning and world-renowned fruitcake and pecan cake batters. Instead of being baked inside circular bundt pans, we hand-scoop the batter into perfectly proportioned cake bites. 

Perfectly baked and covered in our signature honey glaze, our Petites are the ideal snacks for those too hungry to wait for the turkey timer to ding!

Collin Street Bakery’s flavors of Petites include: 

Thanksgiving is a time to savor not only the bounty of the harvest but also the joy of being with loved ones. And there’s no better way to celebrate this cherished holiday than with a table filled with the best treats that warm the heart and create lasting memories. So browse our current selection of seasonally-specific desserts on our specials page and order your treats today!


Please login to comment.

Don't have an account?

Sign Up for free
Search engine powered by ElasticSuite
© Collin Street Bakery Accepted Payment Methods
American Express
Diners Club