The Best Cheesecake Flavors, Ever!

Plus, A Limited-Edition Cheesecake Flavor Is Now Available

Dinner isn’t complete without a slice of something sweet. That’s what we firmly believe. And, since you’re here reading our blog, we think you might believe that too. So, since we're all on the same page, we can skip the introduction and just jump right into the subject at hand–cheesecakes.

Our bakery is famous for our fruitcakes—like, really famous. This means it’s pretty easy for anything that’s not a fruitcake to get shuffled to the side. But, here is God’s honest truth: our cheesecakes are really good—like, really good. They simply don’t get enough credit.

That’s why we’re on a mission to spread the word about our best cheesecake flavors. Plus, just for funsies, we’ve revived a limited-edition flavor. Keep scrolling to learn more about our iconic cheesecake collection and to discover what flavor is back for a short period of time.

New York-Style Cheesecake

Our New York-Style Cheesecake is an all-time classic made with real dairy butter, rich cream, and whole eggs, sweetened with all-natural honey. Hand-poured atop our homemade-style, graham cracker crust and baked till perfectly golden brown, each slice is dense and velvety. One bite and you’ll know why this flavor has brought praises from dessert connoisseurs across the nation.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Made with a thick band of traditional cheesecake filling, layered atop a band of strawberry-infused filling, our Strawberry Cheesecake is a beautiful, two-toned dessert. Set on a homemade-style graham cracker base, we bake our cheesecake till just set. Best enjoyed accompanied by fresh-picked berries, a slice of this cheesecake is as irresistible as a bowl of fresh strawberries and cream.

Blueberry Cheesecake

Made with flavorful, juicy blueberries, our Blueberry Cheesecake is a fruit fanatics' dream. We begin by creating our signature cheesecake filling, made with real dairy butter and rich cream flavored with sweetened condensed milk. After the filling is combined, we gently fold in handfuls of whole blueberries, careful to keep each berry intact. This way, each bite of cheesecake is bursting with real berry flavor.

Key Lime Cheesecake

Our Key Lime Cheesecake is the perfect dessert alternative for those debating between a slice of key lime pie or a slice of our New York-Style Cheesecake. That’s because we’ve infused real key lime juice into our classic cheesecake filling, so each slice is singing the tune of the tropics. Tangy and smooth, sharp but creamy, our Key Lime Cheesecake takes your tastebuds to an island paradise.

White Chocolate Macadamia Cheesecake

Made with handfuls of chopped macadamia nuts incorporated into our classic cheesecake filling, our White Chocolate Macadamia Cheesecake is an addicting balance of creamy and crunchy textures. Sweetened with just a touch of honey, we bake our cheesecake till perfectly set and golden brown before generously decorating it with a ring of white chocolate chips and white chocolate shavings.

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin is no longer just for fall. That’s why our Pumpkin Cheesecake is available year-round. Made by incorporating rich, pumpkin puree and warm, seasonal spices into our traditional cheesecake filling, this flavor is perfect for anyone wanting to trick their tastebuds into thinking it’s the holiday season.

LIMITED-EDITION FLAVOR

Pineapple Cheesecake

Our Pineapple Cheesecake is a tropical twist on a classic dessert. Made with real dairy butter, rich cream, and whole eggs, our cheesecake filling is silky and smooth. For a tangy pop of pineapple flavor, we add a generous helping of crushed pineapple. Thoroughly mixed and hand-poured atop our sweet, graham cracker crust, we bake each cake till perfectly set. Close your eyes while you enjoy each bite, and you'll think you’ve drifted off to an island paradise.

SOLD OUT!

LIMITED-EDITION FLAVOR

Cookies N’ Cream Cheesecake

For all you big kids out there, our Cookies N' Cream Cheesecake is the dessert for you. It combines our classic cheesecake filling with a generous helping of crushed Oreo® Cookies and white chocolate chunks. Poured atop our cocoa-infused, graham cracker crust, this cheesecake is an addicting combination of creamy and crunchy textures.

SOLD OUT!

LIMITED-EDITION FLAVOR

Praline Pecan Cheesecake

Our Praline Pecan Cheesecake is a Texas twist on a Louisianan classic. Made with a crunchy and crumbly graham cracker base, we fill this cheesecake with our classic, creamy filling loaded with pecan praline nuggets. Sweetened with real sugar and flavored with pure vanilla extract, this recipe tastes as big and bold as a brass band on Bourbon Street.

SOLD OUT!

Now's Your Chance to Choose a Cheesecake Flavor

Our mission is complete! We’ve officially spread the word about our stellar cheesecake collection. We did a mighty fine job if we do say so ourselves. But hey, our job was easy. You have the hard part–deciding on which flavor to order! Remember, our limited-edition flavor isn’t sticking around forever. So if you want one, you have to order now.

**All cheesecake flavors are subject to availability. To get these featured offers, click on the product photos or button. No promo code is required. Offer not valid with other offers. Offer not valid on previously placed orders.